|
Page 1 of 3 Macguide Issue 12 (Co-written with Hitendra Patel) Digital camcorders have been around for years - what made them truly usable was Apple's adoption of the FireWire connection standard, and the bundling of iMovie with OS X. In other words, connect most FireWire-equipped camcorders to a Mac with a FireWire cable, and your movie is not only imported into your machine, it's also editable in iMovie. And that's all for no extra cost, and regardless of what software ships with cameras - none of which we installed for this guide, I might add. The cleverness of this is a good lesson for technology companies in general. Demonstrate it to a school or any video-shooting enthusiast and the attraction is obvious, the enthusiasm palpable - the ramifications for professional users are also simply impossible to miss. For example, MacGuide enlisted the expert help of documentary maker Hitendra Patel for this guide - Hitendra is about to buy a Mac suite for himself, after extensive research into the pros and cons of computer platforms and digital video. None of the cameras we tested were listed on Apple's compatibility chart, but they all worked flawlessly with iMovie. Getting images off SD and CF cards via USB was a different matter; for some you'd need a card reader unless drivers are released. Another advantage of shooting to a card is good, emailable QuickTime (MPEG 4) movies can be made in almost no time at all. All the cameras had extensive ranges of accessories available. As usual, we didn't try digital zooms - we only like optical. Pulling pixels apart pleases no-one, and should only be used in desperation. All the cameras were either very well laid out, or well laid out. With many, opening the LCD reveals another panel of buttons, but the two Sony Mini 8s dispensed with this - instead using touch screen controls on their LCDs directly, which gave us some concerns. Also, check whether bottom-loading tapes will be a problem, as most cameras have this - for lots of tripod shooting, it is a pain: you have to unmount the camera every time you change tapes. This is a large model using the older technology of Digital 8 tape, but the 355E has a good feel and shape. Manual functions give it some standing as a serious model, the menus are easy-to-use and there are features aplenty, including effects like slim, sepia, black and white, and mosaic to give you more control over the end result if you don't like playing around in editing software like iMovie or more full-featured packages. Another real bonus is 16x9 widescreen mode. The zoom is good, for a button-controlled one - it's smooth and easy to control - but the steady shot is not that effective and manual focus is clumsy, virtually precluding any tricks like pull-focus - but the auto focus is effective enough in conjunction with the zoom. The eject button was a little difficult to find and a little stiff, but you'd get used to that. The menu is easy to use, but the manual exposure display doesn't give a vast amount of info. Backlighting tends to blow the image out a bit, but would be fine in extreme conditions. White balance was hard to find, in fact impossible for us as our review model didn't have a manual. You can adjust the audio level but you can't adjust it live, so if you wanted to make a serious short movie you'd just have to hope for the best or add a soundtrack later (but dialogue syncing is difficult). Verdict A good, solid model with good features, apart from a few niggles, and Digital 8 is an aging format. But movie quality is pleasing and we liked the capacity for a plug-in microphone. | Recommended Retail Price | $1316.25 | | Resolution | 0.8 megapixels | | Lens (and zoom) | Sony f2.5 50mm 1:16 with 20x zoom (700 digital) | | Tape format | Digital 8mm (Hi8) plus Sony Memory Stick for still shots | | Battery type | Info-Lithium (lithium-ion) | | Extra features | Built in Memory Stick slot, super steady shot, USB streaming, MPEG Movie EX, super night shot, movie light | | Comes with | AC adapter, rechargeable battery pack, remote control, AV stereo connecting cable, shoulder strap, USB cable (for the still shots), CD ROM for Mac OS 8.5.1 to 10+ (and Windows). | | Further info | www.sony.co.nz/digital/ | | A small, one-handed camera in metallic gunmetal and silver, the PC330E has the innovative feature of a touch-screen LCD, but that's the thing we liked about it least. Apart from the stress this puts on the LCD's hinge, imagine the effect of greasy fingerprints all over your primary viewing device, especially as the optical viewfinder is small (although excellent in quality). Having to control things from the screen also makes hand-held operation clumsy. That aside, the PC330E captures excellent image quality from its Carl Zeiss lens, shooting three megapixels using holographic auto-focusing. Further, it has good features normally seen on bigger models, like a manual focus ring on the lens, innovative live distance measuring displayed on the LCD, 16-9 widescreen, night shot, image stabiliser etc. Lots of accessories are available too, including a wide angle and telephoto converter, and microphone adapters. Verdict Fantastic camera, great features, great movies getting near pro quality; shame about the touch-screen LCD - although having a touch-selectable focus point is cool. | Recommended Retail Price | $3273 | | Resolution | 3.05 megapixels | | Lens (and zoom) | Carl Zeiss Vario Sonar 1.8/5.1-51 | | Tape format | Mini DV, Sony Memory Stick for still shots | | Battery type | Lithium Ion | | Extra features | Still camera function, touch panel LCD, accessory shoe, PictBridge | | Comes with | AC adapter, rechargeable battery pack, remote control, AV stereo connection cable, USB cable, Memory Stick, CD-ROM, lens hood, cleaning cloth | | Further info | www.sony.co.nz/digital/ | | Another touch-screen LCD in a small gunmetal and silver handycam, and again with manual adjustments available, but all via that awkward-in-operation - despite the menus being straightforward - touch-screen (I mean, try focusing with a touch-screen!). But it's nice to handle, with a sensitive zoom - and the touch-screen selectable focus point is a cool feature. Verdict A good point-and-shoot with an annoying touch-screen. | Recommended Retail Price | $1767.37 | | Resolution | 1 megapixel | | Lens (and zoom) | Carl Zeiss Vario Sonar, 10x zoom (120x digital) | | Tape format | Mini DV, Sony Memory Stick for still shots | | Battery type | Lithium Ion | | Extra features | Intelligent accessory shoe, night shot, 12 picture effects, battery info on the LCD, analogue input, Super SteadyShot, pop-up, four-mode flash for still shots, selectable 16:9 aspect ratio | | Comes with | AC adapter, rechargeable battery pack, remote control, AV stereo connection cable, USB cable, Memory Stick, CD-ROM, lens hood, cleaning cloth, shoulder strap | | Further info | www.sony.co.nz/digital/ | | One of the smaller units looked at, but very well designed ergonomically with everything falling to hand, the 10i has all the features you'd expect from a more professional model: manual exposure and focus, manual white balance et cetera. Extra good features, apart from vivid colour capture and good shadow detail, include audio level monitoring and adjustment, and in-camera effects like Art and sepia toning. There's even a simple blue screen capability on the supplied SD card. Verdict A good, compact camera with enough features to please amateur Peter Jacksons. | Recommended Retail Price | $2799 | | Resolution | 2 megapixels | | Lens (and zoom) | Canon 47mm f10.7, 1:1.8, 10x zoom (and 200x digital) | | Tape format | MiniDV plus SD memory card for still shots and MPEG4 QuickTime movies | | Battery type | Lithium Ion | | Extra features | Pop-up flash, Exif Print, PictBridge, super night mode, analogue-digital conversion, image stabiliser, RGB primary colour filter, high resolution wide-screen mode (16:9), digital stereo sound | | Comes with | USB cable, software for OS 9 and X (and Windows), SD memory card, rechargeable battery, AC power cord, AV stereo connectors | | Further info | www.canon.co.nz | |
|